Staff Writer: Keaghan Knight
I pledge allegiance to the flag of the united states of America, and to the republic for which stands one nation under god indivisible with liberty and justice for all.
This oath is recited every morning by millions of students. However I challenge the nationalistic speech, and call it out for manipulation. Children are forced to learn the pledge from a young age, but have no idea what they are reciting. These children cannot be expected to even understand what they are pledging allegiance to, let alone understand what they are mindlessly saying. Let’s take the line “liberty and justice for all”. Does America really follow this, does the LGBT community have equal rights, do women have equal rights in the workplace, and are African Americans being treated equally by our police force?
The pledge originated in 1892 by Francis Bellamy, a Christian socialist and extreme nationalist. It was originally drafted in an attempt to revive americanism among the youth. As a result thousands of schools began reciting the pledge as a part of their daily routine. The image was a classroom full of kids spewing the same thing day after day in unison. The pledge was accompanied by the bellamy salute, which looks very similar to the Nazi salute. If the government of any other country was forcing their children to do the same daily routine they would immediately be criticized. However in America the government cannot force any student to say the pledge of allegiance due to the first amendment. In the 1943 Supreme Court case West Virginia State Board of Education v. Barnette, the Supreme Court ruled that students are not required to say the pledge.
One of the biggest reasons to not say the pledge is the addition of the phrase “under god”. The phrase was added 1954 as a way to distance ourselves from the atheistic communist state that the Soviets adopted. It was only an excuse used during the Cold War to add religious basis to our patriotism. The phrase itself needs to be taken out of the pledge, because it affiliates the government with a religion. “Under god” is clearly referencing the Christian god, and it discriminates against Hinduism, Islam, Buddhism etc. If the pledge incorporated the words “under Allah”, Americans would be outraged. It is time to lose the pledge, and the remnants of the cold war.